Claude Fable 5.1 vs GPT-6 Astra: Benchmark Comparison
Claude Fable 5.1 has the higher score on 13 of 21 shared benchmarks; GPT-6 Astra leads on 8.
The largest observed score gap is 33.97 pts on SRE Bench , where GPT-6 Astra leads.
Reported ±1 standard-error ranges overlap on 7 of 18 shared benchmarks with comparable uncertainty data. This is not a pairwise statistical significance test.
Shared benchmark results
Scores and reported standard errors come from the latest visible Vals benchmark version available for both models.
| Benchmark | Claude Fable 5.1 | GPT-6 Astra | Gap | Reported uncertainty |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Vals RSI Index | 36.09% | 27.07% | 9.02 pts | Uncertainty comparison unavailable |
| Immigration | 75.44% ±1.40 | 67.69% ±1.55 | 7.75 pts | Reported ±1 SE ranges do not overlap |
| Legal Research Bench | 55.29% ±3.46 | 39.42% ±3.40 | 15.86 pts | Reported ±1 SE ranges do not overlap |
| EMB v1.1 | 76.73% ±2.13 | 72.68% ±2.30 | 4.04 pts | Reported ±1 SE ranges overlap |
| Tax Agent Bench | 50.75% ±3.61 | 20.72% ±2.92 | 30.03 pts | Reported ±1 SE ranges do not overlap |
| MedCode | 53.51% ±2.17 | 48.49% ±2.13 | 5.02 pts | Reported ±1 SE ranges do not overlap |
| MedScribe | 91.29% ±1.95 | 87.91% ±1.94 | 3.39 pts | Reported ±1 SE ranges overlap |
| ProofBench v1.1 | 100.00% ±0.00 | 99.00% ±1.00 | 1.00 pts | Reported ±1 SE ranges overlap |
| MysteryMechanism | 47.75% ±3.36 | 53.15% ±3.36 | 5.41 pts | Reported ±1 SE ranges overlap |
| Robo-bench | 5.83% | 23.33% | 17.50 pts | Uncertainty comparison unavailable |
| Terminal-Bench-Science | 40.00% ±5.90 | 62.86% ±5.82 | 22.86 pts | Reported ±1 SE ranges do not overlap |
| IOI | 90.78% ±4.65 | 100.00% ±0.00 | 9.22 pts | Reported ±1 SE ranges do not overlap |
| ProgramBench | 7.00% ±1.81 | 5.50% ±1.62 | 1.50 pts | Reported ±1 SE ranges overlap |
| SWE-bench Multimodal | 61.25% ±2.23 | 43.33% ±2.26 | 17.92 pts | Reported ±1 SE ranges do not overlap |
| Terminal-Bench 4.0 | 58.08% ±3.31 | 59.60% ±4.40 | 1.51 pts | Reported ±1 SE ranges overlap |
| Vibe Code Bench v1.1 | 90.26% ±1.57 | 89.59% ±2.17 | 0.67 pts | Reported ±1 SE ranges overlap |
| CyberBench v1.1 | 70.42% ±5.43 | 41.07% ±2.56 | 29.34 pts | Reported ±1 SE ranges do not overlap |
| SRE Bench | 22.90% ±2.60 | 56.87% ±3.07 | 33.97 pts | Reported ±1 SE ranges do not overlap |
| Financial Coaching Bench | 75.71% ±1.54 | 67.53% ±1.69 | 8.18 pts | Reported ±1 SE ranges do not overlap |
| CUA-bench | 13.17% | 19.17% | 6.00 pts | Uncertainty comparison unavailable |
| Time Horizon Index: KSP | 63.33% ±0.00 | 90.50% ±0.00 | 27.17 pts | Reported ±1 SE ranges do not overlap |
Performance by category
| Category | Claude Fable 5.1 average | GPT-6 Astra average |
|---|---|---|
| Legal | 65.37% | 53.56% |
| Finance | 63.74% | 46.70% |
| Healthcare | 72.40% | 68.20% |
| Math | 100.00% | 99.00% |
| Science | 31.19% | 46.45% |
| Coding | 61.47% | 59.60% |
| Cyber | 46.66% | 48.97% |
| Social Mobility | 75.71% | 67.53% |
Cost and latency
Cost per test appears only where the benchmark reports it for both models. Latency is the measured completion time for that benchmark.
| Benchmark | Claude Fable 5.1 cost | GPT-6 Astra cost | Claude Fable 5.1 latency | GPT-6 Astra latency |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Vals RSI Index | $298.22 | $759.51 | 90h00m | 90h00m |
| Immigration | $2.11 | $1.37 | 7m15s | 8m21s |
| Legal Research Bench | $23.06 | $10.58 | 57m29s | 24m51s |
| EMB v1.1 | $15.93 | $5.83 | 29m32s | 13m24s |
| Tax Agent Bench | $13.18 | $5.80 | 28m34s | 15m01s |
| MedCode | N/A | N/A | 3m35s | 102.86s |
| MedScribe | N/A | N/A | 3m08s | 2m34s |
| ProofBench v1.1 | $2.70 | $1.71 | 7m58s | 5m08s |
| MysteryMechanism | $5.63 | $1.56 | 17m41s | 8m09s |
| Robo-bench | $20.40 | $28.48 | 2m04s | 74.88s |
| Terminal-Bench-Science | $38.01 | $20.80 | 2h36m | 1h49m |
| IOI | $11.20 | $6.50 | 30m06s | 31m40s |
| ProgramBench | $58.52 | $11.57 | 2h27m | 27m02s |
| SWE-bench Multimodal | $5.46 | $1.81 | 15m12s | 7m03s |
| Terminal-Bench 4.0 | $17.18 | $9.58 | 1h00m | 35m42s |
| Vibe Code Bench v1.1 | $33.37 | $38.51 | 57m40s | 39m04s |
| CyberBench v1.1 | $4.01 | $1.84 | 18m32s | 4m10s |
| SRE Bench | $32.23 | $10.24 | 2h03m | 17m51s |
| Financial Coaching Bench | $1.14 | $1.72 | 5m48s | 12m33s |
| CUA-bench | $323.78 | $1821.37 | 37.44s | 32.09s |
| Time Horizon Index: KSP | $4655.01 | $4206.59 | N/A | N/A |
Results available only for Claude Fable 5.1
- LegalBench
- MortgageTax
- TaxEval v2
- GPQA Diamond
- MMLU Pro
- MMMU Pro
- LiveCodeBench
- SkillsBench
- Public Benefits Bench v1.1
Results available only for GPT-6 Astra
- Vals Index
- Vals Finance Index
- Vals Legal Index
- Vals Science Index
- HLAB-Vals-1.1
- Finance Agent v2.1
- BioMysteryBench
- Code Migration v1.1